Myth check: “Anthropic and OpenAI destroyed books, like a Nazi book burning”
Anthropic did cut up millions of print books, but it scanned every page first, so the text survived. OpenAI deleted files, not paper.
What the data shows
The claim: AI companies bought up millions of books, rare ones included, and destroyed them to feed their chatbots, so those books are gone. Posts compare it to the Nazi book burnings of 1933.
What’s true. Anthropic did destroy millions of physical books. A June 2025 US court ruling says that from 2024 it spent “many millions of dollars” on millions of print books, often second-hand. Contractors cut off the bindings, scanned every page and threw the paper away. Files unsealed in January 2026 show the company called it Project Panama and wanted it kept quiet. Counted in copies, that is far more than in 1933, when students burned about 20,000 volumes in Berlin alone.
What doesn’t hold up. Every copy became a scan, so no text was lost. The judge ruled this fair use, because each scan replaced a copy Anthropic had paid for. No one has shown Anthropic destroying a rare book, and it says its programmes don’t buy rare or antiquarian books to destroy. The viral clip of a machine slicing spines came from a used-book business recycling mouldy stock, not from Anthropic. No source shows OpenAI cutting up paper books: in 2022 it deleted two digital training sets that authors say were copied from LibGen, a pirate library.
Why the comparison fails. In 1933, student groups in more than 20 university towns burned books by Jewish, socialist and pacifist writers to purge their ideas. Anthropic was after “all the books in the world”, kept the text and trained Claude on it.
What it means
Millions of paper copies went to recycling, but there is no evidence that any book’s text disappeared. The files Anthropic was made to destroy were pirated ones: its $1.5 billion settlement, about $3,000 for each of some 500,000 books, requires it to delete them.
Caveats
- Nobody outside Anthropic has seen the list of titles it cut up. If a title had only a few copies left, losing one would matter; booksellers suspect this but have shown no case.
- The scans stay inside Anthropic. A second-hand copy someone could have bought is now text only one company can read.
- Anthropic’s statement on rare books is its own word. Amazon is reported to scan books the same way: 404 Media followed a shipment of rare books to an Amazon facility in Las Vegas.
- OpenAI’s deletion matters in court for another reason: authors argue it bears on whether OpenAI copied wilfully. In February 2026 a judge ruled OpenAI need not hand over its lawyers’ messages about it.