PostgreSQL 19 shipped five weeks late; a committer blames AI-found bugs, with fixes up 61%
Robert Haas says bug reports made with AI tools swamped the team. His commit counts rose, but he did not measure the cause.
The PostgreSQL project released version 19 on 19 November 2026. Major releases of the database have come out between mid-September and mid-October for about a decade, so this one is about five weeks past the end of that window. Robert Haas, a long-time PostgreSQL committer (a developer with permission to change the code), wrote on 30 October that “LLMs happened”. He says people are reporting many more bugs they found with AI tools, and the committers have been busy fixing them.
His evidence is commit counts for 8 April to 25 September. Commits to the release branch for the version in progress rose from 724 in 2025 (version 18) to 1,169 in 2026 (version 19), a rise of 61%. Commits to the previous release’s branch rose from 248 to 433, more than 74%. Three large features (UPDATE/DELETE FOR PORTION OF, SQL property graph queries and ALTER TABLE … MERGE/SPLIT PARTITION) were removed from version 19 between 27 August and 15 September.
Haas gives two reasons for the delay. Fixes take human time even when an AI tool drafts them, because the drafts are not always correct or in line with project standards. Review time that would have gone to the new release went to security issues and bug fixes in older versions, so deciding what to remove took longer. He calls the delay itself not especially concerning.
What it means
Bug hunting with AI tools now turns up more flaws than at least one large volunteer-run project can fix on its usual schedule. Haas expects every new feature to be checked by AI soon after it lands, so the extra fixing work may last beyond this year.
Caveats
- The cause is Haas’s reading of the project, not a count of which commits came from AI-found reports. He says it is possible that committers made more mistakes this year, though he does not think so.
- A commit count measures how many fixes landed, not how serious the bugs were or how many reports each fix covered.
- The release announcement does not mention the delay or AI. Willison’s summary repeats Haas’s explanation rather than adding evidence.